Pair finds that, at least when it comes to mining trucks, bigger isn’t always better.
By Donna Schmidt
While haul trucks have generally gotten bigger over time, reflecting better economics in many applications, the opposite is true when trucks are automated – this according to a new report from Pronto and Whittle Consulting.
Pronto and Whittle recently released their joint study “Autonomous Swarm Haulage: The Economics of Autonomous Haulage with Small Trucks” that presents a groundbreaking analysis demonstrating that when mining haul trucks are automated, bigger is no longer always better.
Whittle modeled the net present value (NPV) of mining a representative copper ore body through four different scenarios, taking into account all facets of the mining value chain over an 18-year life-of-mine (LOM) horizon.
Their findings included that the modeled mine operating with a fleet of autonomous 40-ton haul trucks would realize a 31% greater NPV than if the mine were operated with a fleet of manually driven 100-ton off-road haul trucks.
Additionally, autonomy significantly improved effective utilization by reducing truck downtime, standby, and operating delays to 5% of availability versus 20% for manual vehicles. Finally, one theorized flaw in the small truck logic was the prospect of traffic congestion caused by the increase in the number of trucks operating in the mine, potentially overcoming the efficiency gains of small truck and automation.
In the study’s simulations, interestingly, such traffic congestion did not materialize.
“The industry has long debated whether mining economics shift to favor smaller trucks when autonomous,” said Whittle CEO Gerald Whittle. “We’re excited to publish the first rigorous analysis that demonstrates that for most mines – the answer is yes.”
The study also found that converting an existing fleet of haul trucks to autonomous operations increased NPV – irrespective of truck size. Both conclusions are consistent with industry experience and past studies, including Whittle Consulting’s 2018 Autonomous Haulage Report.
“This study is exciting because it clearly articulates one of the many ways in which autonomy is revolutionizing the global economy today,” said Pronto CEO Anthony Levandowski.
“The results also illustrate why our strategy has been centered around making automation accessible to the majority of mines and quarries around the world that aren’t running the Ultra Class trucks that the legacy AHS providers have been focused on.”
Pronto noted it previously demonstrated the commercial benefits of an AHS capable of scaling down to the smallest trucks and smallest operations.
The Pronto-Whittle study substantiates that identifying the specifics of why small trucks are favored when autonomous: lower maintenance costs, better fuel efficiency, faster haul speeds, narrower benches/steeper pit walls are possible, and better overall fleet utilization, among others.